other vols.   |   abstracts   |   editors   |   board   |   submit   |   book reviews   |   subscribe   |   search


 

Education Policy Analysis Archives

Volume 10 Number 37

September 6, 2002

ISSN 1068-2341


A peer-reviewed scholarly journal
Editor: Gene V Glass
College of Education
Arizona State University

Copyright 2002, the EDUCATION POLICY ANALYSIS ARCHIVES.
Permission is hereby granted to copy any article if EPAA is credited and copies are not sold. EPAA is a project of the Education Policy Studies Laboratory.

Articles appearing in EPAA are abstracted in the Current Index to Journals in Education by the ERIC Clearinghouse on Assessment and Evaluation and are permanently archived in Resources in Education.


Appendix to Volume 10 Number 37

The Effectiveness of "Teach for America" and
Other Under-certified Teachers on Student Academic Achievement:
A Case of Harmful Public Policy1

Ildiko Laczko-Kerr
Arizona Department of Education

David C. Berliner
Arizona State University

Complete Data Set

ID

Certification

Grade

TFA

NCE98
Read

NCE98
Math

NCE98
Lang.

NCE99
Read

NCE99
Math

NCE99
Lang.

MATCH

12451

Certified

4

No

47.83

58.81

47.74

45.38

61.34

37.27

1

14014

Emergency

4

Yes

26.81

45.30

40.34

     

1

12551

Certified

5

No

29.76

42.00

27.98

30.58

41.55

35.17

2

14524

Emergency

5

Yes

     

27.17

34.11

30.81

2

13346

Certified

3

No

     

32.35

53.05

43.60

3

14320

Emergency

3

Yes

     

30.50

44.68

40.26

3

14230

Certified

2

No

     

46.10

50.58

36.62

4

13202

Emergency

2

Yes

     

23.25

22.37

16.94

4

15237

Certified

2

No

     

37.01

66.08

43.35

5

14244

Temporary

2

No

40.83

32.07

15.80

31.97

36.13

33.53

5

13345

Certified

3

No

22.25

26.58

34.38

34.85

43.11

39.91

6

14345

Temporary

3

No

     

12.93

10.60

16.60

6

13457

Certified

4

No

25.21

27.80

22.57

27.95

39.42

30.05

7

15458

Temporary

4

No

     

18.05

17.15

26.25

7

14229

Certified

2

No

39.00

40.97

39.10

31.77

42.54

28.65

8

12215

Emergency

2

No

     

30.70

33.49

26.82

8

23474

Certified

4

No

     

46.09

46.23

52.90

9

24426

Emergency

4

No

     

46.89

35.82

49.19

9

267148

Certified

7

No

46.53

45.32

47.19

47.31

49.57

42.29

10

24736

Emergency

7

No

     

25.94

26.57

23.27

10

228101

Certified

8

No

36.26

28.19

33.06

     

11

24861

Emergency

8

Yes

37.21

34.70

34.82

37.67

41.71

38.53

11

13675

Temporary

6

No

27.62

33.21

26.27

27.58

28.12

21.86

12

61611

Certified

6

No

29.51

39.96

30.66

     

12

15887

Certified

8

No

36.58

36.87

33.09

40.64

32.58

35.42

13

24836

Emergency

8

No

35.77

38.04

35.73

     

13

25587

Certified

5

No

44.54

38.23

37.18

45.27

44.71

41.65

14

23520

Emergency

5

No

29.74

31.06

32.50

40.82

43.98

41.69

14

23682

Certified

6

No

36.53

32.15

38.93

     

15

23627

Emergency

6

Yes

26.85

33.90

27.65

     

15

226101

Certified

6

No

     

39.52

47.60

46.34

16

23655

Emergency

6

No

     

15.40

18.90

*

16

22792

Certified

6

No

     

26.64

30.95

26.09

17

23621

Emergency

6

No

     

35.52

29.34

37.99

17

24765

Certified

7

No

42.01

36.12

37.86

34.66

27.52

35.23

18

23755

Emergency

7

No

     

64.90

17.30

*

18

13233

Certified

2

No

37.77

47.87

38.60

45.38

61.34

37.27

19

46252

Provisional

2

No

     

27.97

28.30

17.31

19

34514

Certified

5

No

21.03

35.60

31.28

32.25

40.31

32.23

20

25501

Emergency

5

No

17.47

32.70

15.40

     

20

216119

Certified

6

No

37.61

36.65

37.46

     

21

25602

Emergency

6

No

26.17

40.94

23.55

     

21

23276

Certified

2

No

     

48.83

25.39

35.15

22

22328

Emergency

2

No

40.26

38.21

32.03

39.70

48.40

33.60

22

265109

Certified

5

No

     

32.65

33.03

40.38

23

22552

Emergency

5

No

     

43.56

37.70

42.20

23

263149

Certified

3

No

     

19.27

23.75

17.14

24

50327

Provisional

3

No

     

20.64

21.99

31.30

24

275124

Certified

5

No

     

37.18

28.95

39.64

25

22512

Emergency

5

No

36.35

37.61

29.30

44.50

54.71

43.31

25

276131

Certified

6

No

31.20

32.36

27.28

41.31

35.48

36.30

26

27046

Emergency

6

No

43.86

52.24

47.60

42.18

39.93

33.52

26

276132

Certified

6

No

     

18.94

28.86

17.12

27

22652

Emergency

6

No

     

42.84

43.30

42.43

27

24364

Certified

3

No

     

29.82

40.32

30.77

28

26318

Emergency

3

No

     

25

29.31

26.45

28

22299

Certified

2

No

38.34

36.01

32.73

48.74

51.87

43.11

29

21254

Emergency

2

No

     

27.34

34.92

30.43

29

275125

Certified

5

No

     

11.34

28.11

20.31

30

21563

Emergency

5

No

     

26.59

28.64

23.56

30

265104

Certified

5

No

42.80

34.93

43.77

47.93

43.36

45.47

31

21503

Emergency

5

No

     

36.41

24.14

39.52

31

22290

Certified

2

No

35.75

50.60

28.40

32.53

35.11

26.95

32

28250

Emergency

2

No

     

31.04

31.88

31.64

32

212140

Certified

2

No

73.70

64.20

64.20

34.28

47.63

34.71

33

51212

Provisional

2

No

23.53

29.87

17.47

32.21

39.99

26.51

33

288137

Certified

8

No

     

17.18

24.68

17.49

34

28834

Emergency

8

No

     

32.09

37.70

45.46

34

287133

Certified

7

No

     

30.47

34.80

35.05

35

27751

Emergency

7

No

     

46.68

36.98

56.74

35

33408

Certified

4

No

32.45

40.20

34.65

35.31

36.90

34.49

36

33409

Emergency

4

Yes

     

42.44

47.23

40.02

36

36624

Certified

6

No

     

34.13

44.11

39.78

37

34612

Emergency

6

No

     

32.07

43.88

28.88

37

43340

Certified

3

No

26.58

29

36.44

29.75

38.82

34.29

38

41313

Emergency

3

No

23.24

27.15

26.03

26.23

26.02

32.58

38

44536

Certified

5

No

     

28.06

29.38

31.82

39

46508

Emergency

5

No

28.56

39.24

30.95

25.06

27.23

24.85

39

47444

Certified

4

No

     

29.79

35.61

33.92

40

42422

Emergency

4

Yes

     

23.33

22.83

29.16

40

42521

Certified

5

No

     

27.50

28.83

36.69

41

42507

Emergency

5

Yes

     

31.81

35.14

31.44

41

43737

Certified

7

No

     

43.78

43.57

42.05

42

42708

Emergency

7

Yes

     

38.41

44.55

38.38

42

56314

Certified

3

No

     

42.83

54.01

47.66

43

44309

Emergency

3

No

     

33.10

41.58

44.71

43

263108

Certified

3

No

18.07

22.15

16.87

39.75

39.61

36.51

44

58332

Provisional

3

No

     

40.74

48.08

50.62

44

44738

Certified

7

No

     

35.65

33.68

37.99

45

44730

Emergency

7

No

     

26.58

28.27

27.15

45

42203

Certified

2

No

27.99

33.57

24.81

39.58

44.60

30.71

46

45206

Emergency

2

No

     

27.90

23.81

25.12

46

47443

Certified

4

No

25.01

20.43

22.47

23.55

29.23

27.91

47

45439

Emergency

4

Yes

     

28.08

34.80

35.18

47

42625

Certified

6

No

     

34.36

39.63

26.63

48

45634

Emergency

6

Yes

     

33.04

37.93

30.06

48

46306

Certified

3

No

22.10

22.63

32.77

30.96

30.67

36.58

49

46323

Emergency

3

No

     

24.90

23.31

28.64

49

42622

Certified

6

No

26.76

31.14

23.68

     

50

46617

Emergency

6

No

34.86

28.76

23.25

32.82

38.85

26.06

50

47515

Certified

5

No

     

26.19

26.67

27.08

51

47544

Emergency

5

No

     

21.26

21.06

20.19

51

47645

Certified

6

No

26.16

33.30

30.30

     

52

47604

Emergency

6

No

36.46

42.09

29.53

     

52

48628

Certified

6

No

     

33.67

36.29

28.64

53

47605

Emergency

6

Yes

     

27.89

29.71

23.67

53

49628

Certified

6

No

28.20

46.80

24.20

38.27

57.13

37.47

54

47638

Emergency

6

Yes

     

25.62

26.18

24.13

54

47742

Certified

7

No

37.25

35.07

39.17

27.29

31.77

25.08

55

47702

Emergency

7

No

     

31.06

39.76

35.84

55

35719

Certified

7

No

40.64

43.80

44.76

41.55

41.69

41.72

56

47704

Emergency

7

Yes

     

27.25

36.94

31.37

56

43811

Certified

8

No

     

38.81

32.33

33.26

57

47818

Emergency

8

No

     

36.39

37.54

31.44

57

42216

Certified

2

No

     

58.53

47.38

46.71

58

48210

Emergency

2

No

     

31.64

35.84

21.92

58

274124

Certified

4

No

     

44.77

51.70

47.53

59

48412

Emergency

4

Yes

     

31.13

46.07

39.53

59

49716

Certified

7

No

27.31

29.97

24.58

19.18

28.16

24.58

60

48703

Emergency

7

Yes

     

31.15

37.62

35.81

60

56513

Certified

5

No

     

42.62

42.11

39.64

61

53515

Emergency

5

No

     

32.95

40.13

35.99

61

55745

Certified

7

No

     

36.57

36.17

42.24

62

57707

Emergency

7

Yes

19.90

32.98

32.20

22.08

24.43

11.35

62

264107

Certified

4

No

31.70

34.42

21.77

30.65

33.61

29

63

59450

Provisional

4

No

     

25.73

32.74

28.89

63

49819

Certified

8

No

     

32.25

42.65

17.05

64

57825

Emergency

8

Yes

     

19.63

33.37

19.36

64

61616

Certified

6

No

     

29.28

34.92

27.88

65

61624

Emergency

6

No

     

56.15

52.83

51.22

65

35821

Certified

8

No

42.07

42.70

32.59

39.47

37.42

36.36

66

59817

Emergency

8

No

     

38.15

37.83

35.37

66

265105

Certified

5

No

     

52.82

43.81

53.91

67

66525

Emergency

5

No

     

39.11

52.47

42.40

67

31604

Certified

6

No

     

38.33

38.23

33.43

68

31605

Temporary

6

No

     

35.62

34.08

32.87

68

31601

Certified

6

No

     

52.39

63.71

53.07

69

36627

Temporary

6

No

     

46.68

46.74

40.13

69

50235

Certified

2

No

41.30

43.34

31.72

     

70

55226

Temporary

2

No

22.60

32.84

16.74

     

70

50202

Certified

2

No

33.86

40.24

30.41

     

71

57229

Temporary

2

No

24.02

24.42

13.19

26.46

26.62

21.01

71

63313

Certified

3

No

43.88

44.48

49.48

50.53

55.19

55.05

72

41301

Emergency

3

Yes

36.10

39.98

39.48

31.86

35.32

43.06

72

22893

Certified

8

No

39.95

38.45

36.60

     

73

57819

Emergency

8

Yes

35.37

36.91

30.87

     

73

34315

Certified

3

No

     

31.11

30.45

40.80

74

34317

Provisional

3

No

     

27.56

25.55

31.62

74

31403

Certified

4

No

     

34.68

44.64

42.29

75

34418

Provisional

4

No

     

35.10

38.67

36.63

75

22291

Certified

2

No

46.13

44.75

40.25

46.99

49.51

39.55

76

43251

Provisional

2

No

     

23.86

28.26

17.90

76

54234

Certified

2

No

26.66

30.33

21.49

33.11

41.23

33.23

77

44209

Provisional

2

No

     

30.73

32.48

30.06

77

58235

Certified

2

No

     

29.32

38.91

34.41

78

45231

Provisional

2

No

     

33.41

29.71

31.84

78

49527

Certified

5

No

35.46

51.07

31.14

     

79

47510

Provisional

5

Yes

29.95

37.85

30.14

     

79

49530

Certified

5

No

     

40.64

53.23

36.93

80

47533

Provisional

5

No

     

30.29

23.26

32.48

80

56436

Certified

4

No

42.39

39.76

43.61

34.63

41.09

37.09

81

48405

Provisional

4

No

     

23.39

27.29

29.66

81

59421

Certified

4

No

     

32.32

37.13

36.32

82

59446

Provisional

4

No

     

21.06

36.56

29.28

82

64708

Certified

7

No

40.33

36.27

41.12

39.23

34.97

38.74

83

61709

Provisional

7

No

40.35

48.01

46.09

     

83

34213

Certified

2

No

31.86

26.10

23.61

48.39

43.21

41.38

84

67223

Provisional

2

No

     

50.84

62.09

54.60

84

33607

Certified

6

No

37.71

49.30

29.05

35.11

53.01

32.36

85

22608

Emergency

6

No

23.94

30.50

23.49

43.90

32.80

32.90

85

35620

Certified

6

No

37.16

36.60

30.39

     

86

22610

Emergency

6

No

12.51

19.95

10.92

     

86

36223

Certified

2

No

     

36.53

40.68

30.59

87

28258

Emergency

2

No

     

28.30

37.03

31.56

87

23827

Emergency

8

Yes

     

39.39

38.24

37.01

88

45848

Certified

8

No

     

27.82

33.68

29.09

88

61601

Certified

6

No

     

34.40

40.11

32.28

89

58601

Emergency

6

No

     

31.42

34.17

26.67

89

66322

Certified

3

No

     

63.17

56.23

56.13

90

60353

Emergency

3

Yes

     

29.10

28.40

34.72

90

22889

Certified

8

No

32.06

24.41

35.03

     

91

13719

Emergency

8

Yes

46.60

39.85

43.25

     

91

228100

Certified

8

No

     

34.18

40.95

40.26

92

12705

Emergency

8

Yes

     

25.47

32.48

31

92

278127

Certified

8

No

     

31.36

31.04

28.89

93

12717

Emergency

8

Yes

     

47.57

47.97

46.12

93

22789

Certified

7

No

41.59

40.57

41.31

     

94

15725

Emergency

7

No

36.53

41.88

41.30

28.61

33.46

29.91

94

227100

Certified

7

No

     

25.08

35.45

35.62

95

13718

Emergency

7

Yes

37.98

36.81

33.23

35.07

37.11

37.05

95

61817

Certified

8

No

34.07

41.93

28.56

     

96

14810

Emergency

8

Yes

32.92

33.04

33.45

     

96

15676

Certified

6

No

39.88

42.97

33.10

26.20

34.24

27.45

97

24636

Emergency

6

No

     

39.70

48.40

33.60

97

267103

Certified

7

No

     

35.74

34.89

38.57

98

57739

Emergency

7

No

39.15

39.50

39.99

30.40

36.81

31.45

98

61804

Emergency

8

No

     

49.12

48.93

46.67

99

278130

Certified

8

No

     

35.96

29.67

32.92

99

14453

Certified

4

No

     

24.79

32.68

30.45

100

61414

Emergency

4

No

     

44.57

58.45

46.49

100

14232

Certified

2

No

42.86

35.89

23.09

15.56

17.25

19.81

101

63215

Emergency

2

No

     

8.75

50.15

40.42

101

34516

Certified

5

No

     

35.04

51.12

28.62

102

13565

Temporary

5

No

26.36

31.44

30.99

22.62

24.31

27.57

102

287135

Certified

7

No

37

34.74

32.77

     

103

13886

Temporary

7

No

23.50

26.93

24.37

43.50

44.62

39.50

103

287137

Certified

7

No

     

44.19

41.54

49.65

104

14782

Temporary

7

No

33.36

36.82

35.06

36.97

34.89

37.22

104

277124

Certified

7

No

     

39.56

35.39

37.79

105

57723

Temporary

7

No

     

35.30

38.75

41.29

105

264109

Certified

4

No

28.12

32.64

12.98

     

106

62406

Temporary

4

No

28.52

39.43

32.97

     

106

61821

Temporary

8

No

     

33.88

38.05

30.58

107

278124

Certified

8

No

     

38.63

35.70

39.92

107

12669

Temporary

6

No

35.94

37.65

37.06

32.79

40.28

28.76

108

44637

Certified

6

No

29.15

34.34

27.77

     

108

13785

Temporary

8

No

40.38

43.88

33.41

39.15

45.72

36.67

109

61802

Certified

8

No

36.72

41.42

31.65

     

109

Note. * Indicates missing data