Should Achievement Tests be Used to Judge School Quality?


  • Scott C. Bauer University of New Orleans



Achievement Tests, Educational Quality, Elementary Secondary Education, Evaluation Methods, Parents, Principals, School Effectiveness, Scores, Standardized Tests, Test Content, Test Items, Test Use


This study provides empirical evidence to answer the question whether student scores on standardized achievement tests represent reasonable measures of instructional quality. Using a research protocol designed by Popham and the local study directors, individual test items from a nationally-marketed standardized achievement test were rated by educators and parents to determine the degree to which raters felt that the items reflect important content that is actually taught in schools, and the degree to which raters felt that students' answers to the questions would be likely to be unduly influenced by confounded causality. Three research questions are addressed: What percentage of test items are considered suspect by raters as indicators of school instructional quality? Do educators and parents of school-age children differ in their ratings of the appropriateness of test items? Do educators and parents feel that standardized achievement test scores should be used as an indicator of school instructional quality? Descriptive statistics show that on average, raters felt that the content reflected in test questions measured material that is important for students to know. However, for reading and language arts questions, between about 20% to 40% of the items were viewed as suspect in terms of the other criteria.


Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Scott C. Bauer, University of New Orleans

Scott C. Bauer (Ph.D., Cornell University) is an assistant professor in the Educational Leadership, Counseling, and Foundations Department in the College of Education at the University of New Orleans, and Director of Research at the School Leadership Center of Greater New Orleans. His research and teaching focuses on the application of the principles of organizational behavior and development to the study of school leadership, organizational change and restructuring. Dr. Bauer's most recent work deals with designing and implementing site-based decision making systems in schools.




How to Cite

Bauer, S. C. (2000). Should Achievement Tests be Used to Judge School Quality?. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 8, 46.